🎄 Know a family that needs help this holiday season? 🎄 NOMINATE HERE!

🎄 Know a family that needs help this holiday season? 🎄 NOMINATE HERE!

Water Heater Replacement

Indianapolis Water Heater Installation

When your old water heater starts to act up, water heater repair is probably the first solution you’ll try. However, it may be time to start thinking about water heater replacement. If the way water heats is no longer energy efficient, the tank water heater or tankless water heater is leaking, or if it is almost to the upper limit of its average lifespan, replacing a water heater with a new one may be the best solution for your home.

There are two main options when it comes to the type of water heater you can choose – conventional water heaters, which are also known as tank water heaters, and tankless water heaters. Each water heater type will heat water using a different process, so it is important to choose the one that will best suit your needs. There is also fuel type to consider – do you already have gas lines in your home, or will you need to have new electrical wiring installed?

When you call Mr. Plumber for assistance with installing a water heater, a licensed plumber can help you compare the two types of water heaters so that you can make the best decision for your home. Learn about water heater replacement for electric water heaters, natural gas water heaters, and propane water heater models for tank style and tankless unit options. We are happy to provide you with an estimate covering all water heater replacement costs, including installation costs and labor costs, as well as additional cost factors that are required to complete water heater installation.

Water Heater Emergency?   CALL (317) 660-4919  Calls are answered 24/7/365

Get Professional Help with Replacing a Water Heater Today

Are you ready for a new water heater to be installed in your Indianapolis area home? The Indianapolis plumbers of Mr. Plumber are experts who are always replacing a water heater in the nearby area! Our tank style water heater replacement services are available throughout the Indianapolis area, and each licensed plumber on our team is one of the best in the business. If you’re interested in learning more about water heater replacement for your residence, don’t hesitate to contact us today.

Replacement Services for Tankless Water Heaters in Indianapolis

Do you want a tankless water heater replacement? If so, Mr. Plumber is here to assist you. We’ll advise you in selecting a tankless water heater that suits your home’s particular hot water requirements while staying within your installation costs budget. Select among both natural gas water heater units or electric water heater models, each of which come with a variety of features! A licensed plumber can also assist you with upgrading outdated tank water heaters to modern tankless heaters that operate with any fuel source!

Whenever you choose our team to install a water heater in your Indianapolis area home, you can feel confident that your new tankless unit will be installed correctly and will operate at the energy efficiency level that you anticipate. Tankless water heaters can break down at any time, demanding a new water heater be installed. When water heater replacement is needed right away, just give us a call!

How Do Tank Water Heaters and Tankless Water Heaters Differ?

Choosing between a conventional water heater or a tankless one when you need to replace a water heater? If you’re unfamiliar with the differences, Mr. Plumber can help you!

A conventional hot water heater heats up a tank of hot water ahead of time. Tank size is an important consideration for both electric water heaters and natural gas water heaters, so make sure it’s sufficient enough to hold as much water as you’ll need during the highest-demand time period.. What happens if you run out of hot water? You’ll be stuck waiting 10-15 minutes for your water heater to turn those icicles back into hot water.

Meanwhile, tankless units don’t need storage tanks because they don’t store heated water; instead, they produce it instantly on demand when needed using the gas burner and an electric heating element. Because hot water is produced on demand, there’s no waiting around for the hot water supply to refill. However, it is important that you choose the proper flow rate when you buy a new tankless unit, as this will determine how much water heats at one time. Make sure the flow rate is sufficient for all hot water activities that could be conducted at the same time in the home.

Average Lifespan of Water Heaters

When it comes to heating water in Indianapolis area homes, one of the most common appliances used are tankless heaters. Tankless units are generally more energy efficient and last longer than their counterparts, the tank style water heater. If you have a tankless water heater, expect an average lifespan around 20 to 30 years.

If your existing water heater is a conventional water heater model, it is highly likely you won’t receive as many years of service from this appliance as you would from its tankless cousin. Expect to replace a water heater tank model every 8 to 12 years instead.

Signs You Need to Replace a Water Heater

Age is an important consideration when deciding whether or not to replace your water heater. But there are also other reasons why you might want to consider getting a new one:

  • If you’ve had trouble with the performance of your water heater, even though it was running well at first.
  • If the sediment in your tank is making it difficult to maintain the water temperature setting.
  • If you find that your annual energy bill has gone up for no discernible reason.
  • If you want energy efficient models with safety device features like an automatic shutoff valve or power venting.
  • The pilot light repeatedly goes out.
  • The hot water lines and cold water lines don’t differ much in temperature.
  • The water heater’s vent pipe allows combustion air and exhaust to leak out.

Equipment Decisions When Replacing a Water Heater

In order to make an informed decision regarding your new hot water heater, it is important to consider the factors involved and then weigh them against each other.

  • Do you want something smaller? If so, then tankless models might be more ideal for you as they take up less space than conventional tank style heaters (which could also prove advantageous if space is at a premium in your household).
  • Will one type of water heater work with your existing electrical wiring and fuel type? If your home doesn’t have gas piping, this may mean you choose an electric water heater unit versus a natural gas unit. Even if your home does not have a gas line currently installed, it may be possible to add gas lines and a gas control valve so that you can use a gas water heater for heating water. Adding a gas line can protect you from fluctuations in electrical fuel prices.
  • Tankless water heating units typically consume less energy than conventional tanks because they dont have to heat water all day long like an electric or gas water heater with a tank.
  • Costs of replacing an existing water heater with another tank model are relatively affordable compared to replacing it with a tankless model. However, this investment in water heaters that are tankless can save you lots of money over time since you’ll need much less energy for water heating needs in total, including water through plumbing fixtures, dishwashers and clothes washers – not just hot showers!

Water Heater Replacement Costs

We know you’re probably curious about what kinds of water heater installation fees are included in water heater replacement costs. Does replacing a water heater tank unit with a tankless water heater cost more than water heater installation with another tank water heater? Is it more expensive to replace a water heater before it breaks down, or should you wait until it completely fails before spending money on a new water heater?

There are many different types of water heater costs that can affect your final prices when getting a new hot water heater installed. Tankless water heater costs are generally higher than conventional model prices, as these water heaters are more energy efficient and require more complex installation expertise, increasing the labor costs. An electric model of either water heaters type is generally more affordable than natural gas units. According to average costs, you may pay around a thousand dollars for the most basic, minimal energy efficient performance tank water heater model installation, or several thousand for high energy efficiency tankless models.

Who Is MAX?


Max is an important part of our team. He is more than just a cartoon character. Max represents our commitment to quality work, craftsmanship, pride, and our passion to serve our clients and community. We celebrate this mentality through Max because these are the values that drive us to be the area’s most complete and comprehensive home service company. So, now when you see Max, you’ll know the story behind the man with the mustache!

Our Coverage Area

Subscribe for Savings and Tips in Your Email!